Pie-Eyed Pizzeria
Adam G · 248 Google reviewsPie-Eyed Pizzeria — dependable italian in Fulton Market. Hospitality you can feel from the door, and open late. "They give the best service and the food is so delicious" — Mon Roe [$]
What 446 diners keep saying
What 446 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“The staff was super cool. They play awesome music here and the deep dish was amazing”
“Went in for a couple of slices and perfect timing a new pie came out that looked so good I got 3. Love this place!”
“I love this place! If you’re ever in the area and are looking for good pizza, appetizers, vibes this is the SPOT!! The prices are also great for good quality food and the staff is always welcoming! Best pizza in the area!”
“we really enjoyed hanging out and having dinner here!!! the pizza crust is thin and super crispy, and the meatball sandwich had that perfect little bit of sweetness to the sauce. my nephew was really vibing with the music playing 😎 oh and the garlic bread is perfect, i loved the crunchy outside but soft buttery salty garlicy inside. i love garlic bread”
“Came in with my sister and my son for dinner, we were promptly greeted by the most friendly guy at the front counter! The food was absolutely AMAZING! Thin, crispy crust, melty cheese & the most delicious pizza sauce. I ended up purchasing a shirt and my son was bummed he didn’t get one, so the gentleman at the counter went and found their smallest size for him! Such a great experience and although we live out of state, anytime I visit Chicago ill be sure to swing back”
“Literally just had the most amazing vegan pizza there. 10/10 would recommend!!!!! Best in Chicago”
“Great! Just moved nearby and gave it a try. Fresh basil on the hit the spot. Was hot and right out of the oven. Hoped to have some for lunch tomorrow - that’s not happening. We’ll be back often to grab a slice on our way home.”
“BEST SLICES IN THE WHOLE CHI TOWN HEART SHAPED PIZZA FTW FOR YOUR ITALIAN BABE”
“I ordered Pie Eyed for the first time on Galentine’s Day. I got a heart shaped pizza and it was absolutely fantastic. Not only was the pizza incredibly cute, it was flippin delicious. I’ll be back often ❤️🍕”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More Italian in West Loop & Fulton Market
See the ranking →
In the same lane · Italian, budget
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in Fulton Market, minutes away.