Mart Anthony's Italian Restaurant

Name: Mart Anthony's Italian Restaurant
Address: 1200 W Hubbard St, Chicago, IL 60642, Chicago, IL, 60642.0, US
Telephone: +1 312-421-3477
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.7

Essential

Italian·Soul Food·Steakhouse

Is this your business?

Claim this profile to update your info and track analytics.

Claim Profile

About

Mart Anthony's Italian Restaurant — top-tier italian in Fulton Market. Classic neighborhood feel, nothing here chasing trends. The bar is worth the visit on its own, and owner on site.

Experience Breakdown

🍴Food

5.0

👥Service

5.0

✨Ambiance

5.0

💬Sentiment

4.8

Alex Sandoval

214 reviews

Highlights

CozyOld SchoolFamily FriendlyGreat CocktailsOutdoor DiningQuick BiteHidden GemInstagram WorthyNeighborhood InstitutionFamily Run

What Diners Are Saying

Diners loved

Patio/outdoor seatingAuthentic flavorsWarm, welcoming staffCozy, intimate spaceOwner on site

Some noted

I was looking for a nice Italian restaurant that could serve a good meat lasagna.

Location

1200 W Hubbard St, Chicago, IL 60642

What 509+ diners say about Mart Anthony's Italian Restaurant

We have passed this place plenty of times and have always wanted to try it, we finally did and were so happy we did! The food was delicious! That staff were extremely friendly! The Christmas decor - great! The outdoor seating is covered and heated and it feels like you’re inside actually! Loved it! The portion sizes were large! We split the lasagna between two people and it was more than enough! We’re definitely going back! My mom had the spaghetti and meatballs and loved it! She also had a Bloody Mary and said it was so good! Kudos to mart Anthony’s! Thank you! We made reservations so we didn’t have to wait for a table. There is valet but we found street parking! There are a couple steps to get into the restaurant and a step down to get to the outside section

“We had an amazing private dinner for 30 out on their patio.”

We had an amazing private dinner for 30 out on their patio. 5 course wine paired dinner. Stunning table decor and grilled tomahawks! Thank you so much to the staff, Mike and Marc. We will be back. I was so busy eating, only got a few pics

Jennifer Martin

Oct 2025

“Tonight we had the two weekly appetizers (not pictured).”

Tonight we had the two weekly appetizers (not pictured). Stuffed mushrooms with crab, and shrimp and scallops, perfect. Plus the tortellini, rigatoni Danielo, and Mart Anthony filet (pictured). Exquisite food and service. Lifelong Chicagoan here. Mart Anthony never misses. Always a fun time here. Also, thank you team for stocking good tequila 🙏🏽.

Cecilio Martinez

Oct 2025

“The best real Italian food I’ve had in many years.”

The best real Italian food I’ve had in many years. The Oysters Rockefeller were outstanding and pure bliss. The Tagliatelle with Bolognese sauce and Marscapone Cheese was the best Italian food I’ve ever had. We also sampled the Rigatoni with sausage and peppers and wow it was delicious and authentic. The second generation, old school fine dining Italian is not to be missed. The wine list is excellent. The Cabernet Sauvignon from California was velvety, smooth and left a perfect finish in your mouth. The Tiramisu is some of the best I’ve ever had. Restaurants like this family owned operation don’t exist in Chicago anymore. This is truly a gem with outstanding food, and restaurant.

Anne Gryllakis Roberts

Apr 2025

“Authentic, old school Italian place with a super welcoming vibe.”

Authentic, old school Italian place with a super welcoming vibe. I had the Chicago style bar pizza, which was exactly as it should be, crispy and perfect with a drink.

Josh Friedman

Mar 2025

“If Frank Sinatra were alive, this is where he'd be dining—Mart Anthony’s is hands-down the best...”

If Frank Sinatra were alive, this is where he'd be dining—Mart Anthony’s is hands-down the best Italian restaurant in Chicago! From the moment you step in, the warm and welcoming owner, John, makes you feel like the most important person in the room. The food? Absolutely phenomenal. My favorite dish is the Chicken Saltimbocca, but the sugo and the sausage with peppers are just like my Nana used to make—pure comfort on a plate. The new outdoor patio is magical, like dining inside a snow globe, complete with heated floors to keep you cozy. The valet guy is incredibly kind, and every server is the epitome of perfection, ensuring an unforgettable experience every time. If you're looking for authentic Italian food served with love and old-school charm, look no further than Mart Anthony’s. It’s a true Chicago gem!

lisA fRosT

Jan 2025

“This is an amazing establishment with a wonderful ambiance, attentive and friendly staff members,...”

This is an amazing establishment with a wonderful ambiance, attentive and friendly staff members, and food that makes you feel like love was put into it just for you. I personally loved the Italian sausage and peppers!

Jay Shipinski

Dec 2024

“Great food, atmosphere and service.”

Great food, atmosphere and service. Loved the pasta and have leftovers for tomorrow

Audrey Waechter

Dec 2024

“Great Food and wonderful service.”

Great Food and wonderful service! Staff is very attentive. Will definitely be back. The lasagna was delicious and also tasted delicious as leftovers 😁

Angelica Porras

Aug 2024

“The place from outside looks more like a bar, but it’s definitely a little hidden gem if you’re...”

The place from outside looks more like a bar, but it’s definitely a little hidden gem if you’re looking for delicious Italian food. I, myself, not a big fan of Italian kitchen, but this place is definitely worth it! The food is good quality and very flavorful. It’s not a very spacious place, and you definitely need a reservation, but is very cosy looking inside. Parking is tough, but they do offer valet service. Grilled calamari was delicious! Salmon was oceanic, didn’t know it came with pasta, which wasn’t bad, but the fish and vegetables were delicious. Cannoli was pretty good, but not the best, however cappuccino was very good! The waiter was okay, but was a little too busy, and could definitely do a better job of coming by a little more frequently. The owner was very nice!! Don’t come to Downtown areas too often anymore unfortunately, because of the safety concerns, but if someone wants to come here and drive, definitely would come back!

One In A Billion

Jan 2024

“We had a wonderful experience at this place.”

We had a wonderful experience at this place! The service was great, the cocktails were delicious, and the atmosphere was perfect. The food was excellent too. The staff made us feel very welcome😊

Cindy Recinos

Dec 2023

“I was traveling alone in Chicago and decided to stop by for dinner on their beautiful front patio.”

I was traveling alone in Chicago and decided to stop by for dinner on their beautiful front patio. Despite being the only person dining outside, the staff frequently checked in on me to ensure I was comfortable and enjoying myself. Everything was delicious (I had the fettuccine lucia and a side of meatballs, as well as a glass of cab), the staff was incredibly friendly, and the patio was a great spot to enjoy the cool weather. I will definitely be returning the next time I’m in town!