Pie-Eyed Pizzeria

“Great! Just moved nearby and gave it a try. Fresh basil on the hit the spot. Was hot and right out...”

Great! Just moved nearby and gave it a try. Fresh basil on the hit the spot. Was hot and right out of the oven. Hoped to have some for lunch tomorrow - that’s not happening. We’ll be back often to grab a slice on our way home.

David Otto

Nov 2025

“Awesome pepperoni, mushroom and Italian beef pie.”

Michael Henderson

Jul 2025

“BEST SLICES IN THE WHOLE CHI TOWN HEART SHAPED PIZZA FTW FOR YOUR ITALIAN BABE.”

Edwin Tolentino

Feb 2025

“I ordered Pie Eyed for the first time on Galentine’s Day.”

I ordered Pie Eyed for the first time on Galentine’s Day. I got a heart shaped pizza and it was absolutely fantastic. Not only was the pizza incredibly cute, it was flippin delicious. I’ll be back often ❤️🍕

Liz Hammond

Feb 2025

“The pizza is thin but it’s delicious the restaurant is cool it gives off a gothic like chill vibe to me at night.”

The pizza is thin but it’s delicious the restaurant is cool it gives off a gothic like chill vibe to me at night. The guy who wears the hat and has glasses picks and chooses who he wants to be nice to but whatever overall I’d come back can’t beat $6 pizza

Tiara

Sep 2024

“Great place to eat with the family.”

Great place to eat with the family! The garden pizza, chicken strip, sweet & sour shrimp, fries, cheese curds, root beer was all amazing!!! Service was A one! Cool laid paid atmosphere very vintage. I’m from Brooklyn felt like home and now at least found a new pizza place in my new city.

Krystal Marie (Ispykrys)

Aug 2024

“Been back twice already, highly recommend anything and everything.”

Been back twice already, highly recommend anything and everything. I just moved to the neighborhood so I have high expectations for the rest of River West after Pie-Eyed pizzeria. I’ll be back

Mr. Kellogg

Apr 2022

“Wow what a Deep dish !”

Wow what a Deep dish !! Got the custom basil and sausage deep dish. The sauce and cheese are so good. Felt it the next day but worth the feast. Medium will stuff two people with crazy appetites. 3 people with good appetites.

Spencer Gradley

May 2021

“Yes!!! Loved it. Had the 16” ‘Monster Pie’. Sooo delicious. Not greasy. Perfect thin crust. The...”

Yes!!! Loved it. Had the 16” ‘Monster Pie’. Sooo delicious. Not greasy. Perfect thin crust. The extra sauce was just what this pizza needed (that’s how it comes). Highly recommend and can’t wait to try more pies!

Rachael Link

May 2019

“This is some serious deep dish.”

This is some serious deep dish. Took a chance on a random pizza place in chicago, but lets be honest, the odds are high it will be awesome. Not disappointed one bit. The jalapeno poppers were super cheesy and the pizza, good lord, the sauce was boss. The toppings of roast beef and hot Giardiniera was a perfect fit. On a cold, rainy and snowy April day, we took this beast to a bar across the street and got 1000s of compliments. The smell was to die for. Good job guys.

Adam G

Apr 2019

“I would come here just for the music.”

I would come here just for the music! Always playing good 90's alt. Pizza by the slice with daily specials. Stopped in for the 5 dollar Tuesday special, two dogs fries and a pop!

Santana Adame

Aug 2018

“I'm only in this area once a month and Pie-Eyed Pizzeria is a scheduled stop every time.”

I'm only in this area once a month and Pie-Eyed Pizzeria is a scheduled stop every time. Big slices of delicious pizza. I always have the cheese and sausage. The pizza is always served piping hot, just the way I like it. They also sell cookies. I recommend the oatmeal raisin.

Michelle Jones

Feb 2018