Nonna's Pizza & Sandwiches
Is this your business?
Claim this profile to update your info and track analytics.
About
Nonna's Pizza & Sandwiches — clean, consistent italian in West Loop. 456+ Google reviews. Brian Williams: "The filet was amazing, Perfectly prepared and well seasoned"
Experience Breakdown
Samir Katta
190 reviews
“Next time I come, I will probably try the meatball sub even though they have a good variety of cold sandwiches and pizza”
Highlights
What Diners Are Saying
Diners loved
Some noted
I went to this place every week for a year.
Waiting 25 minutes for a cold turkey sub that came out on stale bread with 2 thin slices of turkey.
So bummed … read the google reviews and ordered via door dash for delivery to hotel.
Location
925 W Randolph St, Chicago, IL 60607
What 456+ diners say about Nonna's Pizza & Sandwiches
“Best chicken parmesan sandwich in the city.”
Best chicken parmesan sandwich in the city. Only for take out. Shared half and was stuffed, good value and good packing.
Lynn Tukiendorf
Jan 2026
“The chicken parm sandwich is simply amazing!”
The chicken parm sandwich is simply amazing!! Chicken breading is not too thick, the marinara sauce is very flavorful. The baguette did not get soggy, and it didn’t not hurt the roof of my mouth. Big portion too so one sandwich is good for two ppl! Definitely will be back
May Bentley
Dec 2025
“The Drunken Chicken sandwich was great.”
The Drunken Chicken sandwich was great. Delicious bread.
Kevin Austin
Dec 2025
“Incredible sandwich’s.”
Incredible sandwich’s. The line is worth the wait. Limited seating but it turns over. Bread is perfect to provide a firm bite but not tear up your mouth….you sandwich guys know what I’m saying.
Andrew Kelly
Aug 2025
“Oh… My… God!! What a damn delicious sammy!!! I got the mushroom melt…and like others have said...”
Oh… My… God!! What a damn delicious sammy!!! I got the mushroom melt…and like others have said about this place…hands down the best sandwich! Highly recommend stopping in. I also got a lemon bar and a tiramisu parfait and they were both delicious as well. So happy I got to experience this place, and will forever being dreaming of this sandwich
Jeremy Chance
Aug 2025
“New chicken Caesar wrap is pretty solid.”
New chicken Caesar wrap is pretty solid! The chicken is grilled rather than breaded, I wish they had both options. The croutons taste like their breaded chicken cutlets. I opted for no red onion. It was a good wrap!
Anastasia Vikanova
Jul 2025
“Cute little walk up shop for sandwiches and pizza.”
Cute little walk up shop for sandwiches and pizza. Tuna sandwich was pretty good but I’d argue it was a little overpriced at $15. Pizza slice was a great deal and the slice was huge. Flavor was fantastic as well. Had a few small tables to sit at outside and enjoy the hustle and bustle of the city.
Chris Horntvedt
Jul 2025
“Had the pleasure of sampling two outstanding sandwiches.”
Had the pleasure of sampling two outstanding sandwiches. First up, the chicken parm sandwich, which truly impressed. The sesame bread brought a good crunch, and the thickness of the chicken was just right. The sauce was tasty, though a dash more fresh basil would've elevated it even further. Next, I tried the "What The" sandwich--a real flavor explosion. I'm typically not into eggplants, but the crispy, battered slices here were a game changer. The serrano peppers gave a spicy kick, perfectly offset by the spicy-sweet mayo. Both sandwiches were substantial and satisfying. Definitely recommend stopping by to try these subs.
Kenan Al. Mahayni
Apr 2025
“The photo should tell you everything.”
The photo should tell you everything. Perfect crust, slightly burnt pepperoni, DIVINE sauce, great cheese. There’s just nothing I would change about this slice. If you’re in Chicago, you gotta go!
Sai Akhil Satyavolu
Mar 2025
“If you’re not going here, you’re doing yourself a disservice.”
If you’re not going here, you’re doing yourself a disservice! The entire menu, top to bottom, is outstanding. The sandwiches, pizza, even desserts…wow. Don’t miss out! On “Restaurant Row” of Chicago, this is THE ONE.
Cameron Thompson
Oct 2024
“One of my favorite slices of pizza in all of Chicago.”
One of my favorite slices of pizza in all of Chicago. It’s a New York size slice, and has the best crispy crust. The pepperoni slices are a larger size, the sausage chunks are good sized. You want to try a slice here. Soon.
Devodare_Chicago
Jul 2024
“Was there on Monday July 8th and the girl working was very hospitable and professional.”
Was there on Monday July 8th and the girl working was very hospitable and professional. I appericate her help very much the new york pie is for taking home and the Detroit style is for eating there is my rule for this restaurant. Nice little patio for great weather days like today!
Christopher Blaker
Jul 2024
Love Nonna's Pizza & Sandwiches?
First Bite — Coming Soon
Our monthly Chicago food newsletter — new openings, hidden gems & trending spots.
More Italian in West Loop & Fulton Market
Top-rated spots serving the same cuisine.
You Might Also Like
Similar style & budget — Italian, budget.
Different Cuisines in West Loop
Try something new without leaving the neighborhood.
