The Fish Guy

“Outstanding lobster roll.”

Outstanding lobster roll! Chunks of lobster meat lightly dressed in an herbed mayo and served on a great New England-style roll. It's definitely the best I've found in Chicago, and the price can't be beat. The side of vinegar-based cole slaw (with red bell pepper) acts as a bright palate cleanser between bites. You've made this New Englander very happy! Check out the rest of the store, too. The display case is filled with so many delicious seafood options. There are also a lot of sauces, beverages, and tools to help with your seafood adventures.

Laura DeLassus

Dec 2025

“Lovely gourmet shop where you don't expect it.”

Marc Stone

Dec 2025

“Aaron and his team were absolutely wonderful from start to finish.”

Aaron and his team were absolutely wonderful from start to finish. They provided an incredible in-home dining experience for our group of 20+ guests, with fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented dishes. The appetizers and full course dinner was delicious — you could truly taste the quality and care that went into the food. Beyond the amazing meal, the service was wonderful. The team was attentive, professional, and so thoughtful, making sure every guest felt taken care of (considerate of all dietary restrictions among our group). We all had such a lovely evening! If you’re looking for a top-notch catering experience with fresh seafood and excellent service, I highly recommend The Fish Guy.

Holly Hatlo

Oct 2025

“Tons of great food and wine options at the Fish Guy.”

Tons of great food and wine options at the Fish Guy! Highly recommend. The new owner has really made this place look sharp—he’s clearly a man of impeccable taste.

Stone Conroy

Jun 2025

“This is a fantastic take on a traditional New England style lobster roll, in which the cooked...”

This is a fantastic take on a traditional New England style lobster roll, in which the cooked lobster chunks is served as a lobster salad on a toasted split top bun. The lobster salad was amazing and the portion size is robust!! The dressing on the cold hunks of lobster was simply made of mixing mayo, celery, lemon juice, salt and pepper. I tasted a hint of dill but was delicious nonetheless. There is no in-store seating allowed and all prepared foods or purchases are to-go. The shop is simple decor, just fresh seafood to pick-up and go. This is a quiet hidden gem in Albany Patk. The staff was friendly and accomodating. Well worth the visit for this amazing lobster roll.

Rolo

Feb 2025

“This is a great place to get extremely good quality seafood.”

This is a great place to get extremely good quality seafood. The prices reflect this quality, but they always run different sales. They also change up their selections often so each visit will offer you some interesting opportunities. They also serve a lunch menu of you can make it in during the lunch hours.

Brian Chan

Feb 2018

“Tried there Lobster Roll, but more of a Lobster Salad Roll, but if you're in a hurry and on a...”

Tried there Lobster Roll, but more of a Lobster Salad Roll, but if you're in a hurry and on a budget, quite a fun lunch option in the neighborhood!!

Paul Kraneis

Jul 2025

“This place is legit.”

This place is legit! They have all the seafood you could ever want plus they are so knowledgeable and helpful! Everything we have ever gotten here has been such good quality.

nikta pirouz

Dec 2025

“Stopped in there to treat myself after a long workweek.”

Stopped in there to treat myself after a long workweek. I've always been a seafood lover but the better quality is often hard to come by unless you're willing to pay up. And this place is not inexpensive. When I left this place I knew a lot more than when I stepped inside, thanks to the folks working there. Came home with a highly recommended fluke filet (summer flounder from Massachusetts waters) and sauteed it up for dinner and. Oh. My. Incredible. Also have tried the Monkfish...which was good. Will be back for that occasional indulgence in high quality fish or shellfish. I want to try the sushi grade salmon at some point. I know my cats do too.

Regina

Dec 2025

“I stopped in on for the first time and Johanna was a delightful help with my weekly dozen oysters.”

I stopped in on for the first time and Johanna was a delightful help with my weekly dozen oysters. Excellent, fresh, clean storefront. Reasonably priced. It's a fine Chicago seafood establishment!

Jon Buck

Dec 2025

“Very knowledgeable and go beyond expectations.”

Sebastian Ignaciuk

Nov 2025

“Such a great neighborhood gem.”

Such a great neighborhood gem. The selection is always fresh and interesting. Has definitely pushed me out of my comfort zone of only cooking salmon and that's in good part to the staff that is soooo knowledgeable. Will always has a cooking suggestion of how to prepare if I'm stumped. Just an overall great establishment.

Andrea

Nov 2025