The Supreme Burrito #1

Name: The Supreme Burrito #1
Address: 843 Dodge Ave, Evanston, IL 60202, Evanston, IL, 60202.0, US
Telephone: +1 847-733-2927
Price range: $
Rating: 4.5

Recommended

Mexican

Is this your business?

Claim this profile to update your info and track analytics.

Claim Profile

About

The Supreme Burrito #1 — solid, no-fuss mexican in Evanston. Technique and tradition show up on every plate. Friendly without hovering, and easy on the wallet. "Fresh & tasty burritos, savory salsas, and sublime guacamole & chips" — Matthew Parrilli

Experience Breakdown

🍴Food

5.0

👥Service

5.0

✨Ambiance

4.3

💬Sentiment

4.5

Virna Garcia

156 reviews

Highlights

Family FriendlyQuick BiteTakeout StrongGreat ValueFast ServiceNeighborhood InstitutionFamily Run

What Diners Are Saying

Diners loved

Authentic flavorsWarm, welcoming staffGreat prices

Some noted

I've been coming to The Supreme Burrito #1 for years, but I'm officially breaking up with this place.
— Emily Hannon

Delivered a burnt burrito. Said they knew it was brunt, but wanted a picture to refund my money.
— Nichi

Location

843 Dodge Ave, Evanston, IL 60202

What 875+ diners say about The Supreme Burrito #1

I walked in here for the first time just because I had to wait for someone in the area and I was hungry. Wow wow I feel so lucky I found this place! Amazing food! I’ve tried taco salad, shrimp and steak taco. All so good!

“Supreme Burrito #1 always hits the spot.”

Supreme Burrito #1 always hits the spot! Fresh & tasty burritos, savory salsas, and sublime guacamole & chips. The staff is always welcoming & friendly. Recommended for dining in or carrying out.

Matthew Parrilli

Sep 2024

“Awesome!! delicious food. Very affordable. Staff are kind and give a positive vibe to this place”

Kyle Yacoben

Aug 2023

“Mouthwatering food.”

Mouthwatering food! Everything tastes so good. Plus the employees are really friendly and helpful. I felt very welcomed. I will definitely be back.

Kevin U

Jul 2023

“Best handmade chorizo I’ve had in a while.”

Best handmade chorizo I’ve had in a while. My current favorite is a queen burrito, with everything but no cheese. The sour cream is supreme on its own in this burrito. The red or chile de árbol salsa is my favorite with any of their items. Get a cheese quesadilla as well, it’s worth it. The owner is nice and right to the point. Food is quick and piping hot, tortillas fresh and well toasted. Sorry guys. But this ones a destination I try to eat at as much as possible. Oh most people can’t love without the al pastor but el chorizo owns my heart ♥️ 🤤

Axel Erk

Dec 2019

“An Evanston favorite, and with the neighborhood locals, for generous portions and authentic flavor.”

An Evanston favorite, and with the neighborhood locals, for generous portions and authentic flavor. A hole in the wall. And that’s a compliment.

Mark Ingraham

Apr 2018

“While it's not gourmet, this place hits the spot with fast, fresh, reasonably priced food.”

While it's not gourmet, this place hits the spot with fast, fresh, reasonably priced food. One of our favorite places for a quick lunch. Lots of vegetarian options too!

Diana M

Jun 2023

“I’m a contractor, I try new places all the time, This place is REALLY GOOD, First time came with...”

I’m a contractor, I try new places all the time, This place is REALLY GOOD, First time came with workers Second time with my family Both times packed 20$ a person With drink Staff super chill

Mushroom Castle

Mar 2023

“This little restaurant it's in the corner of Main and Dodge.”

This little restaurant it's in the corner of Main and Dodge. It's very popular the food is served so quickly it's amazing at the speed they work. I recommend the carne asada nachos. I tried the chicken burrito I didn't like the flavor of the Chicken. A lot of people order to go I ate there. It is very affordable . I'm definitely going back. Este es un pequeño restaurante en la esquina de la main y Dodge sirven la comida tan rápido Qué es increíble. los precios están muy comodo. Yo definitivamente regreso allí.

Virna Garcia

Sep 2022

“The. Place is clean and the food is decent. Service could improve, cashier has an attitude that...”

The. Place is clean and the food is decent. Service could improve, cashier has an attitude that kills tue vibe. Refried beans were a bit too salty.

Phil S

May 2019

“I'll give this place 3 stars, not because it's bad but because some of their dishes are just plain...”

I'll give this place 3 stars, not because it's bad but because some of their dishes are just plain mediocre compared to their Al pastor tacos or enchiladas. Give it a shot at the "menudo" (soft belly skin on spicy stew) if you are not afraid of real Mexican flavor.

Fausto “Atole” Aguilar

Nov 2017

“I've been coming to The Supreme Burrito #1 for years, but I'm officially breaking up with this place.”

I've been coming to The Supreme Burrito #1 for years, but I'm officially breaking up with this place. Won't be back again. They've messed up my order every time I go. I ALWAYS specifically ask for cilantro and onion, but most of the time, they give me lettuce and tomato instead, which I hate. This time, they got my order right, but it was WAY overpriced! $20 for a 3 taco dinner and horchata? The dinner comes with a drink, but the guy at the front charged me full price for the horchata instead of just an upgrade fee. The food isn't very good anyway - all of my recent orders have lacked flavor. Limes apparently don't exist here. I have to drown these in salsa just to semi-enjoy it. Taco Bell is better at this point. Lastly, I get bad vibes from the guy at the front who overcharged me. And since other reviewers say he likes to help himself to credit card tips after you leave, I don't doubt it, and I will be watching my bank account.