Gigio's

“We went for a group event and ordered 3 extra large pizzas.”

We went for a group event and ordered 3 extra large pizzas. Pizza was NY style; piping hot and foldable. The sauce was good, the crust was chewy but not tough. The place is super casual and serves pizza by the slice.

Mark Sherrett

Oct 2025

“When I don’t know what to eat I go to Gigio’s.”

When I don’t know what to eat I go to Gigio’s! Chill place in Evanston, the crew is pretty friendly and they work hard. I always go for the single slices for a quick lunch. The classic cheese pizza never misses either, their dough is perfect just make sure to ask for extra baking time if you want it crispier. They also do fire birria tacos! The whole menu is great you’ll always find something good here 👍🏻

Serenity Lolmaugh

Sep 2025

“Been a favor of our families for years.”

Been a favor of our families for years. If we could give it higher than five stars, we would the pizza is excellent. The Mexican food is excellent. The salads are fresh ingredients. We can’t say enough good things!!!

Shana Sternstein

Aug 2025

“Classic pizzeria with gluten free options, unique appetizers and classic sandwiches.”

Paige Evans

Jul 2025

“One of my favorite places when we go to Evanston.”

One of my favorite places when we go to Evanston. Today was very busy. Love their sandwiches. Prices are reasonable. Be back.

Georgia Salazar

Nov 2024

“Never disappoints.”

Never disappoints. I buy it for a friend who lives further west. He is from Evanston and enjoys the pepperoni pizza (half baked) whenever he can get it!

Laurie McDevitt

Jul 2024

“10/10 first timer 2 slices of pizza $10 Pretty good I’m used to JB’s in Roger’s Park but very fresh & hot slices.”

10/10 first timer 2 slices of pizza $10 Pretty good I’m used to JB’s in Roger’s Park but very fresh & hot slices. Will be back.

Chelsey Mason

Jun 2024

“best slice of thin crust pizza i’ve ever had in the midwest !”

best slice of thin crust pizza i’ve ever had in the midwest !! fresh out of the oven

Alanna Wong

Mar 2024

“This is a pizzeria that can accommodate a fair number of dine-in customers.”

This is a pizzeria that can accommodate a fair number of dine-in customers. The service is pretty quick and the food delicious. A great neighborhood place to eat. The prices are reasonable and parking should not be a problem. It is also located within walking distance of the Davis El station.

Rodrigo G

Oct 2023

“Old school pizza joint that is so delicious.”

Old school pizza joint that is so delicious. They probably have the best pizza by the slice in Chicagoland area. Also their tacos are very good too. They’re not traditional style but American style with lettuce tomato and cheese but they still hold their own very well. Must have and highly recommended if you’re in Evanston !!

Jason Powell

Sep 2023

“Authentic New York style pizza and experience.”

Authentic New York style pizza and experience. Local pizzeria with checkered tablecloth on the table and juicy oily cheese. Cheap. I would always recommend them over other Papa Johnes or dominos

Vsevolod Suschevskiy

Apr 2023

“fast service, friendly peeps, good prices, yummy comfort food.”

fast service, friendly peeps, good prices, yummy comfort food. chicago dog was great, as was the italian beef (best i've had in evanston), gordita, & meatball sub. i haven't had the pizza, but maybe tomorrow 😁. i think gigios will be on the foodie list for all future trips to evanston.

Mark Cortezzo

Jun 2022