Paulie Gee's Logan Square
Zach Anderson · 159 Google reviewsPaulie Gee's Logan Square — trusted italian in Logan Square. Order the Pepperoni. The kind of place your parents probably knew about too, and solid veggie options. JD McQueen: "Drizzled with spicy honey, fresh tomatoes, crispy pepperoni's and the crust could be sold in a bakery" [$$]
What 1,605 diners keep saying
What 1,605 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“You will be amazed by the dairy-free and plant-based options — taste just as good if not better than dairy cheese. These products have really come a long way and are so much healthier! Vegan items clearly labeled. Crust baked to perfection. Nice atmosphere and wait staff. Food came out very fast.”
“omg, so good. i got the vegan pizza with the cashew ricotta and it was crazy good. not gooey at all. a tad bit gritty but not in a sandy way”
“The staff was truly the sweetest ever. I’ve never experienced this service at a restaurant. The owner came out and talked to us, talked about our trip, and asked us how everything was. It was such a genuine conversation. The server was so kind, and very fast. The pizza maker did an amazing job making the pizza. Truly so good. I recommend this place so much!!”
“Five stars for gluten-free Detroit style pizza that will keep you asking, “is it really gluten- free?” 90s kids want to call the crust “I can’t believe it’s not gluten!” The My Kind of Town and Pizza Cup Winner pizzas are delectable with flavors and textures that are satisfyingly cozy and creative - the balance of toppings hit all the right notes . The service is friendly, knowledgeable, and prompt.”
“As someone diagnosed with celiac in 2022, I’ve tried plenty of gluten-free pizza. Some were good. But the gluten-free Detroit-style pizza at Paulie Gee’s in Logan Square? Next level. Crispy, flavorful, and actually satisfying. Easily the best I’ve had. Highly recommend.”
“We visited it last night just by chance and I'm so happy that we did! Everything was great! service was excellent, pizza was delicious (both Detroit and Wood fire) and the vibe there was just so cool. We have a toddler and I felt it was very family friendly as well. One of the pizza guys made a cute smiley face dough for my daughter and I found it so sweet 🩷 thank you!!”
“Went in right after 5pm with a group of 7 rambunctious, ravenous, elementary-aged boys. The host and server were so kind and very helpful as it was our first time visiting. A+++++ for our server because she knew and understood food allergies and the ingredients of the pizza toppings and did not have to check with the kitchen. It is difficult to eat at new places for our 8 year old that has lots of food allergies. He was able to pick a unique pizza and liked it. And the cherry on top was when his eyes lit up when he read Runaway Cow ice cream, that is our go-to spot! I am excited to visit this Oz-safe place again.”
“Pizza was delicious, good vibe, friendly staff. Would definitely go back.”
“Whoa. I’ve been coming here for a few years now but it just keeps getting better. I dined in tonight and while I was eating my vegan “my kind of town” Detroit style pizza, all I could think of is how I MUST leave a stellar review. The flavor is out of control good. I thought maybe they got rid of some vegan options, but our server Ben mentioned they have an ENTIRE vegan menu which made me so unbelievably happy. Truly some of the best pizza in Chicago and Ben was such an awesome, attentive server. My partner and I couldn’t get over how sweet and lovely he was. Highly recommend!! Thank you :)”
“Took advantage of happy hour apps. I had a local ipa draft. Super tasty. Detroit style pizza was awesome but I preferred the incredible wood brick oven style.. service was right on a atmosphere was chill and fun.”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More Italian in Wicker Park & Logan Square
See the ranking →
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in Logan Square, minutes away.