Paulie Gee's Logan Square
Is this your business?
Claim this profile to update your info and track analytics.
About
Paulie Gee's Logan Square — trusted italian in Logan Square. Order the Pepperoni. The kind of place your parents probably knew about too, and solid veggie options. JD McQueen: "Drizzled with spicy honey, fresh tomatoes, crispy pepperoni's and the crust could be sold in a bakery"
Experience Breakdown
Zach Anderson
159 reviews
“Even if you have leftovers of this pizza it retains the delicious gooey look the next day”
Highlights
Must Try
What Diners Are Saying
Diners loved
Some noted
Terrible experience from start to finish. I placed a takeout order and waited over 45 minutes for just two pizzas.
I placed an order for a gluten-free pizza which I always order for my wife, it has always been great but this time it seems they were in a hurry, I received a pizza with barely any toppings on it, the bacon jelly sauce was very minimal, barely no tomato sauce or pepperoni on it.
A huge fan of the collectible decor that’s what got me in the door 😁 Not the biggest fan of the food or it’s quality.
Specialties
- Pepperoni
Location
2451 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago, IL 60647
What 1,570+ diners say about Paulie Gee's Logan Square
“Took advantage of happy hour apps.”
Took advantage of happy hour apps. I had a local ipa draft. Super tasty. Detroit style pizza was awesome but I preferred the incredible wood brick oven style.. service was right on a atmosphere was chill and fun.
Charlie Burns
Dec 2025
“I just had a gluten free Detroit style pizza and had to come here to tell everyone that this is the...”
I just had a gluten free Detroit style pizza and had to come here to tell everyone that this is the best gluten free pizza I ever had. I got diagnosed with celiac in 2022 and have had a few good pizza. But not like this...must try..so delicious!
GLORIA ESPINOSA
Nov 2025
“Wow...I have to say very good pizza both Detroit style and woodfire pizza.”
Wow...I have to say very good pizza both Detroit style and woodfire pizza. The service was awesome.
Jesus N Ontiveros
Nov 2025
“Ordered the E=MC², elote pizza which was the specialty pizza of the quarter.”
Ordered the E=MC², elote pizza which was the specialty pizza of the quarter. Amazing. So cheesy, so crunchy, so delicious. Our second pizza was US Pizza Cup Winner. Best Detroit pizza we've ever had. The first bite was sweet and basily. The second bite was crunchy pepperoni and bacon jam. Just stop. Bevs: Majeet-O mocktail and The Southern Comfort, which my husband was STRONG. Also get yourself a giant slice of cake (also rotating,we got Nutter Butter, as well as pie!) Check this place out, quarterly special pizzas, yummy bevs and delicious desserts.
A.H. A.
Sep 2025
“The Us Pizza Cup Winner Detroit style could be one of my all time favorite pizzas.”
The Us Pizza Cup Winner Detroit style could be one of my all time favorite pizzas. The crispy cheesy crust, the bacon jam, the ricotta. The tomato sauce it outstanding and all the flavors just come together so well. The pepperoni is crispy and spicy. We also got the So Fresh So Green fireoven white sauce pizza and that was so refreshing. It was a nice earthy arugula flavor and the crust was so soft. The vegan cookies and cream cake was absolutely so delicious, it was from a local bakery and the waiter said the flavor rotates every month. Ben was so friendly and attentive! I love Pauline G’s and can’t wait to be back.
Graham
Aug 2025
“First time here, and we ordered THREE Detroit Style pizzas.”
First time here, and we ordered THREE Detroit Style pizzas. Each one was fantastic! Salads were great, service was great, can't wait to go back!!!!
Larry Benrus
Aug 2025
“I recently visited PAULIE GEE'S and had an outstanding experience.”
I recently visited PAULIE GEE'S and had an outstanding experience! from the moment I walked in the warm and inviting atmosphere made me feel right at home.. The menu offers a fantastic selection of pizzas and I was thrilled to see both classic and unique options.. I decided to try detroit style pizza called (My Kind of Town )and it was absolutely divine! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy.. the sauce was rich and flavorful.. My dining companion ordered the woodfried pizza greenpointer which was equally impressive with a perfect balance of heat and savory goodness. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, ensuring we had everything we needed. Overall paulie gee’s Napoli exceeded my expectations. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just looking for a cozy spot for dinner i highly recommend giving it a try..
iYahyooh Chelsea
Jun 2025
“Stopped here as we just got done moving to the area.”
Stopped here as we just got done moving to the area. Looking for solid pizza to eat after moving all day. As soon as we saw the Detroit Style - "The US Pizza Cup Winner" we knew we had to get that in our belly. The edges CRUNCHY, the middle soft, the hot honey in the background, the ricotta just doing its thing. Great pizza all around. Will be back again!
Jacob Lord
Jun 2025
“The Detroit-style pizza here was SO GOOD.”
The Detroit-style pizza here was SO GOOD. We are from Detroit so are picky about it! The wood fired pizza we tried was good also. Service was fast and attentive. The spot is pretty casual and there was no wait.
Rasmeet Chahil
Apr 2025
“My first visit here and I enjoyed myself.”
My first visit here and I enjoyed myself. I went with a friend and we shared the “my kind of town pizza”- and it was soo good. Beyond what I expected for sure. The sauce, the veggies, the cheeses, the meats were spot on and fresh. 10 out of 10 recommend and will return. Our server was also very nice and provided recommendations and things to us and was so sweet. If you are in the area please check them out you will not regret it.
Vanesha Blackburn
Mar 2025
“We have been coming to Paulie Gee’s for the past 6+ years - it’s a Logan Square staple.”
We have been coming to Paulie Gee’s for the past 6+ years - it’s a Logan Square staple! Highly recommend getting both Detroit style and wood-fired pizzas. The US Pizza Cup Winner is next level. Also, if you dine in, get the cookie skillet sundae - so good!
Alyssa Frehr
Feb 2025
“Paulie Gee's is famous for it's legendary Pizza, one of the best in Chicago.”
Paulie Gee's is famous for it's legendary Pizza, one of the best in Chicago. Rino Siconolfi Instagram rino_siconolfi
Rino Siconolfi, MBA
Feb 2025
Love Paulie Gee's Logan Square?
First Bite — Coming Soon
Our monthly Chicago food newsletter — new openings, hidden gems & trending spots.
More Italian in Wicker Park & Logan Square
Top-rated spots serving the same cuisine.
You Might Also Like
Similar style & budget — Italian, mid-range.
Different Cuisines in Logan Square
Try something new without leaving the neighborhood.
