Chicago's Pizza

“Been taking slices out of this joint for years and I was amazed at the recent remodel for dining in.”

Been taking slices out of this joint for years and I was amazed at the recent remodel for dining in! It is such a beautiful modern and cozy space. Beautifully decorated for the holiday season too. Food was great. The pizza has the most amazing cheese pull. Cocktails where great and the mocktails too. Great dessert selection. Will cone back!

Camila Cediel

Nov 2025

“Nice local pizza place to grab a slice or dine in.”

Nice local pizza place to grab a slice or dine in. They are remodeling the dining area, so they only have delivery and pickup as of March 1st, 2024, so call first if you're looking to dine in. Update the dining area has reopened, and it looks great. They added a bar area, so if you're looking for a few drinks after work and some appetizers, this is a nice neighborhood place that is open late. They are also set up to watch sporting events, and with their amazing pizza and wings, this is a great place to watch the Bears this season 🐻

J. Cordova

Nov 2025

“Great food as always.”

Great food as always. Fresh, moist and delicious. Never a disappointment. Delivery is always on time. Thank you to all who prepared our food.

Jessica Ann Hallam

Sep 2025

“I order Chicago’s Pizza at least once a week.”

I order Chicago’s Pizza at least once a week. Their pizza is always so tasty, fresh and delivered in a reasonable time. They create monthly flavors that are so innovative and delicious, I’ve never met a dish at Chicago’s that i’m not obsessed with.

Azhley Rodriguez

Mar 2025

“Chicago's Pizza from 1991 is one of the best Pizza's Experience in Chicago with an incredible...”

Chicago's Pizza from 1991 is one of the best Pizza's Experience in Chicago with an incredible variety of Pizzas with incredible flavors. Rino Siconolfi Instagram rino_siconolfi

Rino Siconolfi, MBA

Feb 2025

“Phenomenal Gluten Free pizza- incredible caution and safe for highly sensitive celiacs (significant...”

Phenomenal Gluten Free pizza- incredible caution and safe for highly sensitive celiacs (significant other is) and tasty for non Gfree (like me!) Thin, artisan, and deep dish- all Gfree. Deep dish crust is a but crunchy on the edges, but I order it every time it's so good! We had a couple hiccups, potentially a new (but incredibly kind) server, but everything was sorted out without us even asking. Completely satisfied.

Chelsea Gieseke

Aug 2024

“I had a good time, the dining room was empty so I felt like I had the place to myself for about two hours.”

I had a good time, the dining room was empty so I felt like I had the place to myself for about two hours. The Chicago supreme stuffed pizza, the small one, what’s the delectable. The only issue I had, me not used to living or commuting in a city, was finding parking. However, I found parking on one of the side streets and didn’t have to pay for it. This worked out great for me since I ended up staying at the restaurant for about two hours.

Jhön Vènt

Nov 2022

“They offer gluten free crust.”

They offer gluten free crust! Definitely not the best gluten free crust I’ve ever had. It was a little difficult to chew, but it is great to have options. They even brought out some gluten free bread and olive oil, which was a nice surprise! This is only the second restaurant I’ve ever been to that offered gluten free bread before the meal. I loved the atmosphere of the restaurant, but there were only 2 other patrons present and service was pretty slow. It took about 40 minutes from the time I sat down to when the pizza was delivered to my table.

Sarah

Dec 2023

“I got delivered, didn’t take to long for them to deliver it’s about average amount of time.”

I got delivered, didn’t take to long for them to deliver it’s about average amount of time. I have to say this pizza is hefty. I was surprised how heavy it was when I picked it up. I got the Chicago Special Stuffed Pizza, and fried chicken wings. I have to say this pizza is filling has lots of cheese and sauce the crisp crunch from the onions and bell peppers were nice, you can’t really taste the mushrooms and the sausage but overall it’s really good flavor. The wings were good to I was expecting them to be a bit more crispy since I picked the fried option, maybe if they were fresh and not sitting a bag they would have. I still have to say I love a good New York style pizza better.

Kevin Drost

Aug 2023

“I came here the other day to try a cheese slice after hearing great things.”

I came here the other day to try a cheese slice after hearing great things. I paid around $6 for a single slice — only to get a small, oddly cut, cold slice of pizza. Even though their service was friendly and efficient, this is just quite disappointing.

riri

Jul 2025

“Thank you Chicago’s Pizza for offering a gluten-free crust option.”

Thank you Chicago’s Pizza for offering a gluten-free crust option. This is the reason we decided to order from your West Montrose Avenue location. You deserve the five star review on Find Me Gluten Free, but unfortunately the regular crust/stuffed pizza we ordered was raw/undercooked. The fifty-five minute delivery time turned into two hours, so both of the pizza’s were lukewarm when they finally arrived. My husband and I worked in this industry for 15 years, and we feel the top layer of dough was raw, and the bottom layer was undercooked. If this has been the standard for Chicago’s Pizza for 30+ years, and others enjoy eating raw crust, so be it. We do not, and will be looking for other options.

Deanna Decaire

Nov 2023

“I have been ordering from Chicago pizza for over 20 years.”

I have been ordering from Chicago pizza for over 20 years. The food has always been very very good. Last night we had an exceptional meal with pasta, Al Julia and barbecue chicken sandwich and salad. The food was exceptional in delivery as always has been faster than expected. Keep up the great work love having you take care of our meals.

Larry Posen

Jan 2026