Candlelite Chicago

“We were at this place tonight, and due to a small misunderstanding with our reservation, we were...”

We were at this place tonight, and due to a small misunderstanding with our reservation, we were kindly treated to a pizza while waiting for a table — a wonderful gesture from the owner and the kind staff and bartender. But folks, the real revelation was the Candellite White Pizza! We were amazed by the flawless dough and the symphony of flavors that delighted our palates. Absolutely wonderful! See you next year when we visit your city again. Warm greetings from all of us — and as we promised, we’re waiting for you in our beautiful Serbia! P.S. Thank you so much for the lovely gift ❤️

Tatjana Jovic

Nov 2025

“I love candlelight.”

I love candlelight! If you love pizza then you would love this pizza! I order a classic cheese pizza. I always say the first time eating at a pizzeria You gotta get a cheese pizza to taste the sauce, the dough and the cheese. Pizza came out fresh and hot Cut classic squares Chicago style Super thin crispy crust this is more of a Chicago Tavern style pizza then a thin crust pizza. I favor more acidic sauces over sweet. So this sauces was on point for me. Also, their beer selection is pretty decent (Son of juice for my IPA people) Service was amazing! Greeted immediately as we walked in restaurant was packed bar was packed, but was seated right away and the pizza came out so fast (10 minute's) and delicious you would think that the place was empty! The restaurant itself is beautiful with a classic marquee sign outside, love it! 100% Recommend!

Hagz

Oct 2025

“I ordered from here so haven’t been inside but the pizza is pretty awesome.”

I ordered from here so haven’t been inside but the pizza is pretty awesome. Definitely need to go there at some point as well.

Yuan Zho

Oct 2025

“Had delivery and the pizza was awesome.”

Had delivery and the pizza was awesome! Had to drop a review

Justin Heath

Sep 2025

“I was there early on a Sunday afternoon when it wasn’t very crowded.”

I was there early on a Sunday afternoon when it wasn’t very crowded. It was quiet and the service was on point. The pizza was delicious, with a cracker crust and a perfect amount of toppings. I plan to return.

Tina Hardy

Aug 2025

“Wonderful tavern style pizza in a very family friendly place that is perfect to watch sports.”

Wonderful tavern style pizza in a very family friendly place that is perfect to watch sports. Highly recommend this for anyone in the north side looking to have some good pizza

Diego de los Rios

Jul 2025

“Wow! Super busy but seated quickly. Friendly and quick service. Great thin crust pizza. Guy sitting...”

Wow! Super busy but seated quickly. Friendly and quick service. Great thin crust pizza. Guy sitting next to me had a burger. It looked great! Took a pic if it too!

Steven J Brown

Dec 2024

“One of the best pizza places in Chicago period.”

One of the best pizza places in Chicago period! They have borderline mastered the art of pizza making and have great super-fresh high-quality ingredients all around. get the deluxe, it was a big hit at our table. Most definitely will be back!

Andrew Schaefer

Dec 2024

“Absolutely nothing is wrong with this place.”

Absolutely nothing is wrong with this place. From the vintage neon sign to the service to the delicious pizza, Candlelight is top notch in every category. Bartenders don't get any better than Brad.

Jim K

Dec 2024

“Giving five stars out of five because the pizza is fantastic but only if you like very thin pizza.”

Giving five stars out of five because the pizza is fantastic but only if you like very thin pizza. The crust is very much like a cracker and cooks perfect, the sauce has punch which I love, and the cheese is the right amount of oil and flavor and a mix of roller skating rink with gourmet flavor. It’s interesting. I made the buffalo chicken pizza next. All of the flavors you want are there, but the onion is very strong. It’s more like a buffalo chicken dip for an appetizer. It’s really good. I personally won’t be ordering again, but I am absolutely going to recommend them. I prefer thick and chewy but crisp crusts and gooey cheese. This doesn’t do that, but the sauce is right there. I know people who would go absolutely crazy for this. It will be on my recommendations list for them.

Adam Riemer

Nov 2024

“The Candlelite is a Chicago North side institution for years.”

The Candlelite is a Chicago North side institution for years. The outside eating area is pet friendly. Staff is warm and welcoming. Definitely ordering the BLT pizza again.

Thomas Smith

Oct 2024

“I’ve been to Candlelite Chicago a few times now, and it’s always a solid experience.”

I’ve been to Candlelite Chicago a few times now, and it’s always a solid experience. The first time I went was on a Monday, and they had their half-off pizza deal, which is an absolute steal. You’re basically getting buy-one-get-one-free pizzas, but I believe it’s only for the medium and large sizes. Such a great deal! Another time I went, we got the pizza again, and the taste has been super consistent every time. We tried the taco pizza, which was good, but I wasn’t a huge fan of the smokiness that comes from the roasted red pepper. Other than that, it was pretty solid. The veggie pizza is also a hit—classic tavern-style with a crispy, crunchy crust that’s just so good. For appetizers, we got the fries, which were awesome, and you absolutely have to end the night with their cookie skillet. It’s really, really good, though it can be a bit too sweet with all the caramel and chocolate on top. Plus, the ice cream-to-cookie ratio is a little off, but it’s still worth getting. Both times I’ve been, the service was great. The place can get really busy on Mondays, so just a heads-up if you’re planning to go then. There’s street parking right in front that’s usually free at night, which is super convenient. Definitely worth checking out!

Pooja Patel

Oct 2024