Timothy O'Toole's Pub Chicago
SERGELATO · 272 Google reviewsTimothy O'Toole's Pub Chicago — solid, no-fuss american in Streeterville. Always packed, always worth it. Drink selection punches above its weight. Fast service, open late.
What 5,953 diners keep saying
What 5,953 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“Megan, our bar tender was simply amazing! Wonderful service and had a great time!”
“Super fun spot! We ended up coming here on several occasions during our trip because we really enjoyed the atmosphere. Great place to grab a drink, hang out, and just have a good time. The vibe was always fun and welcoming. Definitely one of our favorite casual spots we found in Chicago!”
“Incroyable burger , ambiance au top et service hyper souriant :) au top 👍”
“Good enough to want to order it again; WHILE you’re still sitting there 🏆🏆🏆! Pretzel trio (light cracker crispy shell, perfectly salted with buttery toasted edges) 10/10 Garlic Parmesan 🍟 lightly oil tossed and salted with fresh tasting Parmesan 🧀 8/10 🧅 rings (perfectly golden brown, light chew, NO PULL with dipping sauce 10/10 Meatloaf (on special and going away) with 🥦 (like I seasoned it myself) & perfectly creamed mashed 🥔 with gravy 10/10 🥨 🥖 pudding served warm with vanilla 🍨 & light but tasty caramel sauce which reminded me more of pancake syrup consistency than traditional caramel sauce. Either way it was awesome. 8/10 for me but 10/10 for my brother. I prefer a softer and more wet bread pudding. He prefers more of a cake consistency. POINT IS, buy all of it, NOW. If you don’t love it, I’ll pay for it. Well, really I won’t pay for anything but that won’t matter. You’ll be so happy you tried it. I’m sure every there is good as the team was streaking through the place with purpose the entire time I was there. If you ask for Tiffany you’ll get Tier 1 service. She was fantastic and so cool🤙”
“Visited on March 15, which is the day they die the river extremely busy and they still executed amazingly!”
“Huge great beer selection. Fantastic wings and tons of TVs. I wish we had had more time to hang out and rip some shots watching the Bears come back against the Packers. I bet this place was lit. Will def go back next time I'm in Chicago”
“Local tipo irlandés con gran ambiente y muy animado si te gusta el deporte, con muchas televisiones con todo tipo de deportes. Con gran variedad de cervezas. Fuimos a media tarde porque por la nieve che se suele llenar mucho y no hay sitio para cenar. Nos pedimos una César con pollo que estaba muy rica con el pollo muy jugoso y muy abundante, luego unos finguers de pollo con un crujiente muy auténtico y muy rico y como colofón una Hamburguesa normal pero con el extra de bacon todo regado con unas cervezas locales muy ricas y fresquitas. La atención fue muy muy buena y muy agradable. Lo q no nos gustó mucho es que por ser 7 y considerarse grupo nos cobraron un 20% más y a demás la propina. Volveremos seguro.”
“Your average college student gem. Heard the wings were the best in Chi and decided to stop by. They weren’t frozen (awesome!) but the wings came out dry and cold. Cold. Had to send it back to the kitchen and they said they’d microwave them. Microwaved wings were a bit more juicier bc they were slightly warmer. Didn’t finish. The smashburger came with zero crust. Just your normal burger. Taste was normal. Very creamy though. Truffle tots and coleslaw were okay. Tots were tossed in truffle oil and the slaw was mayo-e. Service was never rude but indifferent to our needs. Just basic. Overall, if all you eat is college campus food and/or franchise food, this is your place. I, on the other hand. had an mediocre experience. I do want to try the wings again under ‘better’ circumstances. Definitely not the best wings in Chi to me for now.”
“Extremely rude service. Upon entering on January 27 around 11pm, I was told to leave a large group alone, the server assuming I wasn’t part of the large work group. We were all meeting up after a work conference. They then told us not to move seats, though we hadn’t ordered yet and there was a card for the table already. Needless to say, I did not order or stay long.”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More American in Downtown & River North
See the ranking →
In the same lane · American
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in Streeterville, minutes away.