Timothy O'Toole's Pub Chicago

“Great little spot for drinks and food.”

Great little spot for drinks and food. Welcoming staff.

Trisha B

Jan 2026

“Huge great beer selection.”

Huge great beer selection. Fantastic wings and tons of TVs. I wish we had had more time to hang out and rip some shots watching the Bears come back against the Packers. I bet this place was lit. Will def go back next time I'm in Chicago

Blake Baldassari

Jan 2026

“Stopped in for a quick drink and ended up really enjoying the atmosphere.”

Stopped in for a quick drink and ended up really enjoying the atmosphere. The food coming out of the kitchen looked amazing, and it definitely convinced us that we’ll be back to try it next time. There were lots of TVs throughout the place, which made it a fun spot to hang out and watch a game. The overall vibe was lively but comfortable, and the staff was friendly and welcoming from the moment we walked in. Looking forward to coming back for food and another visit soon.

Eric Boesen

Jan 2026

“Our go to place for a pretzel when we’re in town.”

Our go to place for a pretzel when we’re in town. Very fresh and brushed in a buttery glaze. Went back the next morning for a Bloody mary and mimosa. Excellent service both times and friendly staff. Good beer, selection and great atmosphere. Also did the Bears bus which was a nice option. Drinks on the bus and a safe ride to the game. My only suggestion would be for the bus to leave earlier as we got to our seats three minutes before the game. Great place to watch most games as well.

Brian Freeberg

Oct 2025

“Jonathan the bartender made my visit welcoming and pleasant.”

Jonathan the bartender made my visit welcoming and pleasant. Will return when Im visiting. Great bar for sports!

David Caamano

Oct 2025

“We loved our experience here.”

We loved our experience here! This is a very cool underground pub. The staff were all incredibly friendly and accommodating to us. The food was 10/10. Very delicious and satisfying. It's a great location within walking distance of our favorite hotel the Warwick Allerton (off Michigan Ave). We love that Timothy O'Tooles is open late because sometimes we arrive in the city later at night and it's fun to have a delicious option that's still open. You need to come here if you like good food and a good time

Emily

Oct 2025

“Always love the experience at Timothy O'Toole's.”

Always love the experience at Timothy O'Toole's! Fantastic location near miracle mile. Wait staff are always helpful and efficient. Solid quality to price value ratio. Solid menu offerings that do not make you feel like everything is fried. Also love the bar choices, particularly the beer list.

H. Calzada

Sep 2025

“the nachos were solid, just classic in preparation and we also optioned for adding on birria to add more flavor.”

the nachos were solid, just classic in preparation and we also optioned for adding on birria to add more flavor. Don’t snooze on their Reuben Egg Rolls which are a direct copy of a reuben sandwich in taste, but the texture of the egg roll was crunchy. A very creative way to have a reuben without comitting to a sandwich. Now it was time for my favorite item here which are their traditional wings. They have a variety of flavors, but we went with their Irish Ghost, Buffalo, and Garlic Parmesan. The Garlic Parmesan was the right ratio of cheesy to garlicky. Crispy exterior, and I really enjoyed these on their own with no dipping sauce. The Irish Ghost reminded me of the Buffalo flavor, but this definitely had a mild kick of spice to it as well. The Buffalo wings were solid, and my favorite combo in bar food history is a nice buffalo wing with some blue cheese. We tried the boneless wings as well with a sticky orange sauce that was sweet and these wings are white meat too.

SERGELATO

Sep 2025

“Always excellent service, beer selection and great food.”

Always excellent service, beer selection and great food. Never come to Chicago without visiting Timothy O’Toole’s. Natalie was amazing.

Ronell Smith

Sep 2025

“This is my favorite bar in Chicago.”

This is my favorite bar in Chicago. The food is absolutely delicious and always fresh, and the atmosphere is great whether you come by yourself to watch sports or with a group of friends. This place has never let me down.

Lior Ofir

Sep 2025

“Tonight quick bite out was delicious and service was friendly and fast.”

Tonight quick bite out was delicious and service was friendly and fast. Madelyn and Keith thank you for the hospitality! The recommendation on the macaroni chicken with bbq sauce was just what I needed! My husband also enjoyed his wings and tots. Thanks again!

Lorie Miller

Aug 2025

“Ask about Sara at the bar, because you’ll get the best (and fastest) service around.”

Ask about Sara at the bar, because you’ll get the best (and fastest) service around. TO’T has a fantastic beer selection and tasty food. You will not have a bad time.

Jon McBain

Jul 2025