Stefani Prime
Michelle Foy · 781 Google reviewsStefani Prime — top-tier italian in Lincolnwood. The cocktail program is serious. Friendly team that sets the tone, and fast service. "The steak was perfectly seasoned and cooked" — Kelly Le [$$$, patio]
What 884 diners keep saying
What 884 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“Me and my friend went to this place to celebrate for his birthday, and our server Yash did not disappoint! He made sure we were taken care of even though it was busy and made our experience UNFORGETTABLE! We will definitely be back for the food and for the lovely atmosphere and service that we received!”
“Delicious all around. We ordered the sea bass special and the risotto. Both were excellent. Drinks and sides also good”
“Great place for special occasions, business dinners, functions, or any occasion. There is so much on the menu to choose from. The food was delicious, and the staff was friendly and very accommodating. Constantly aware of your needs, from refilling your drinks. Excellent service, highly recommended. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”
“The red wine fettuccine in the pasta cheese wheel was AMAZING! I typically don’t add chicken to my fettuccine but I did and it was excellent! My husband’s steak was also delicious. Our fantastic server, Vivian, recommended the bacon wrapped dates (appetizer special) and we loved those also. To add to our wonderful experience they brought out a complimentary slice of white chocolate cake with a birthday candle for my husband’s birthday. We will absolutely be back when we return to the area!”
“The meats are the stars. My 22 ounce rib eye chop with Gorgonzola topping was a dreamy dish. I sampled the veal chop which also was a 5 star performer. Twice baked potato good but not great. Same thing for the side salad - crisp and fresh but not worthy of 5 star billing. Deserts were tasty - my key lime pie was definitely made with key lines - and not overwhelmed by the graham cracker crust. The chocolate cake was massive - over a foot tall! We sat on the patio outside and enjoyed a mild summer evening with almost no noise. All in a superior experience.”
“UPDATE 7/2/2025 Stefani Prime is a great place to eat any night of the week but be sure to make reservations ahead of time as they are busy and book up fast! They have valet parking and the guys do a great job of quick service in and out! All the food on the menu is top drawer quality and doesn’t disappoint! We were celebrating my birthday and boy what a fantastic meal we had. Matt our server was so friendly, made us feel comfortable and didn’t miss a thing! 10 stars for him alone! We had calamari to start then I ordered the 22oz. ribeye which was cooked to perfection. My sister ordered the lobster risotto which was decadent! We also had a NY Strip and Lake Superior White fish. We went on a Tuesday night and the place was packed but then it’s always packed! It was a really memorable meal and the entire wait staff was exceptional! —————————- Stefani Prime is a hidden gem in Lincolnwood. Highly acclaimed by Chicago Tribune and others. Their entire parking lot is Valet and keeps your car and belongings safe. There is a very nice ambience once inside. They have tables, booths, party room and an outside dining area. The outside dining during winter is covered/enclosed and surprisingly very nice. It’s super heated warm from top to bottom and quieter than the main dining area. Mike was our waiter and did an outstanding impeccable job of serving our family. All the servers were so personable before, during and after our meal. I almost felt like we were family. All the drinks, food and service are top drawer here. I had wedge salad, eggplant Parmesan and cookie skillet. The eggplant had a nice flavor and was not overly breaded accompanied with pasta marinara. The pasta was perfect as was the sauce! My sisters and husband each had Veal Piccata and broiled fish. The chocolate martinis after dinner were decadent! They give generous portions and the platings are beautifully rustic and simplistic. You’re not rushed here and all the servers have impeccable timing with food and beverage delivery to your table. Great place for any special occasion or just because you are craving their specialties. They have something for everyone! Thanks for a memorable night!”
“My experience started with a funny exchange with the valet person, he is awesome. I sat at the bar and was greeted by the very efficient and kind Jimmy. Drinks were on point, but the star was the New York strip. Nice char taste and cooked perfectly. The space is beautiful and welcoming, my new favorite place!”
“This is our first visit to Stefani Prime. I wanted to go for quite some time and it's only about three miles from home. We decided to celebrate Mother's Day on Saturday to avoid the crowds. What a great choice! They have complimentary valet parking. Everyone we encountered was very friendly and professional. Our server was Carmen and she was top notch. We ordered drinks and she recommended the Calamari, which was perfect. We ordered two Filet Mignons with a Twice Baked Potato and Shrimp Diavolo. The meals were great. Decided to save some room for dessert, so we split a Creme Brulee and a Key Lime Pie. Again, the service was fantastic all around and I highly recommend Stefani Prime. I'll be back soon. Fun fact: The last picture below is the original Stefani's which was located on Fullerton Avenue in Lincoln Park which I dined at when I was at DePaul University.”
“Easter Sunday Brunch. Great atmosphere and the odd celebrity.”
“Went for my Anniversary with my wife. The Wagyu meatball and the Lobster arancini were delicious. The wagyu meatbal was very tender and flavorful. Itis definitely big enough to share. The Lobster arancini were crisp on the outside and moist and tender on the inside. The Lobster filling in the arancini had shredded Lobster in it rather than chunks and had a mild Lobster flavor. The New York Strip from the specials menu was a bit tough. Not sure if it was the cut of steak ot because it was slightly under the med rare that I ordered. My wife had the Chicken vesuvius. That was absolutely delicious. The potatoes thar came with it had crispy skins with soft tender insides. The chicken was moist, tender, and very flavorful. The canke with the candles is their house made white chocolate mousse cake. This dessert is rich, flavorful, and decadent. It is one of my favorites on their dessert menu but in my opinion needs a cup of coffee or something with it to cut the richness. We also had the trio of Gelato. The flavors currently are hazelnut, chocolate, and vanilla. It is very flavorful and creamy. The chocolate has a flavor that reminds me of a fudgsicle. The hazelnut has a strong natural hazelnut flavor. It does not taste like an extract. The vanilla is light and clean. I would definitely recommend this restaurant and will be going back.”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More Italian in Chicago
See the ranking →
In the same lane · Italian, upscale
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in Lincolnwood, minutes away.