Paulie Gee's Wicker Park

“Several non-meat slice options, quickly heated and came out got, which is great.”

Several non-meat slice options, quickly heated and came out got, which is great. Chewy for a thin crust, slightly less sauce would have kept the crust firmer and easier to eat. Overall a positive stop.

Kovas Palubinskas

Nov 2025

“Solid slices. Would happily go back. Tried the white pie and wolf. White pie def had a strong acid...”

Solid slices. Would happily go back. Tried the white pie and wolf. White pie def had a strong acid note from lemon. Wolf had a nice jam flavor mixed with salty meatiness. Plus $3 old styles and pbrs are a win

Rage Thomas

Aug 2025

“The Wicker Baby with Mike’s hot honey drizzled on top is a full mood—sweet, spicy, & addictive.”

The Wicker Baby with Mike’s hot honey drizzled on top is a full mood—sweet, spicy, & addictive. It hits your tongue like a love letter with a kick & you start to think the honey isn’t the only thing you’d let be on top. . 🫦🔥🍕 Charred, chewy crust in all the right places. Would order again. Would fight someone for the last slice. Service, friendly & cute man (not pictured).

JG

Jun 2025

“Really delicious pizza here with an excellent selection of flavors.”

Really delicious pizza here with an excellent selection of flavors. I got the vodka roni which I HIGHLY recommend, although I wish I could have tried all of them. You get a massive slice of pizza for about $6, which is really good for Chicago prices. Plus, it’s absolutely delicious. The workers were really nice; the man who checked us out welcomed us in and said goodbye as we left. This is an excellent stop, especially if you’re on a budget.

Laura

Apr 2025

“Couldn't have dropped into a more perfect place for a quick bite.”

Couldn't have dropped into a more perfect place for a quick bite. A delicious, fresh slice of pizza with a soda is $8.50.

Postcard Narrative Family Travel

Apr 2025

“I stop for slices here all the time.”

I stop for slices here all the time. All their offerings are good. Vodka roni slice is great 👍the pizza is a little more expensive than most of my other spots but it's worth it. Yum.

Jeff Duyckinck

Aug 2024

“Really good pizza.”

Really good pizza! Online ordering was super easy and the delivery was relatively quick. Lots of pizza toppings to choose from and the pizza itself was HUGE. Really enjoyed the ricotta, basil, and halal beef pepperoni.

Jessica Ali

Jul 2024

“Solid joint for a quick pizza slice.”

Solid joint for a quick pizza slice. Personal favorites are definitely Big Bad wolf & Sausage with giardiniera.

Denise

Jun 2024

“I had heard a lot about this place and we happened to be walking by so I had to pop in and grab a slice.”

I had heard a lot about this place and we happened to be walking by so I had to pop in and grab a slice. They were not the friendliest people but the pizza definitely lived up to the hype. The crust was thin and crispy and the sauce had amazing flavor. I got the wicker baby and it had a perfect amount of spice with the chili oil and the pepperoni added a good amount of saltiness. The slice was over $6 which I thought was a little steep but it was pretty big and definitely worth it. I will be back for sure.

Matthew Schermer

Jan 2024

“By the slice pizza spot right on six corners in Wicker Park.”

By the slice pizza spot right on six corners in Wicker Park. Doesn't have as much variety as Dimos around the corner, but more than makes up for it with quality. Service is fast and the spot itself is a great one for people watching the busy intersection while you eat.

Michael Damato

Dec 2023

“Delicious pizza. Perfect spot to grab a quick bite. The slices are big and fresh. We had the Garden...”

Delicious pizza. Perfect spot to grab a quick bite. The slices are big and fresh. We had the Garden Party and a regular cheese. Place was clean and service was friendly. I’m coming back to try different toppings.

M Bon

May 2023

“Been coming here for a minute.”

Been coming here for a minute. Get yourself a Logan Zaddy pizza (on the right). It’s got pepperoni, bacon jam, ricotta, basil, parm and hot honey. Best pizza they got. Also had the Chicago-Style Hot Dog pizza (on the left). It’s good but a bit too salty for my taste. Music is a bit too loud but they play some good 90s boom bap at times.

arise07

Apr 2023