Nancy's Home of Stuff Pizza
Diana Grossman Tantra Butterfly · 420 Google reviewsNancy's Home of Stuff Pizza — neighborhood italian in Lakeview. The design gives it a sharp first impression. Cocktails here aren't an afterthought. [$$]
What 300 diners keep saying
What 300 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“We had an amazing food and time while watching UEFA , love this place”
“Omg the food is so good! I love their Honeycake desserts. Elif is the best waiter. And when I came back for a second visit my server, Ruhiye, was so nice to my group. Highly recommend the thin crust pizza & beer.”
“If Chicago had an edible crown jewel, it might just be Nancy’s Pizza. From the first step inside, you get that comforting, neighborhood-legend energy, the kind of place where the ovens have stories and the recipes have lineage. The pizza is the headline act. Their stuffed and deep dish pies arrive like architectural masterpieces, golden crust standing tall, layers of cheese and toppings stacked with intention, and a rich tomato sauce that tastes slow, deliberate, and deeply satisfying. Every bite feels balanced, not heavy, just boldly flavorful in the way only true Chicago pizza can be. Service was warm and attentive without hovering. You feel welcomed, not processed. It is the kind of spot where families gather, friends linger, and out-of-towners suddenly understand why Chicago takes pizza personally. Portions are generous, quality is consistent, and the overall experience hits that sweet spot between classic and crave-worthy. Whether you are a lifelong local or just passing through, Nancy’s is not just a meal, it is a proper Chicago pizza experience. Already looking forward to the next slice.”
“Was passing by lakeview area and did a quick stop at this place it was so suprising how this place was transformed, they had full bar, amazing cocktails had too much fun highly reccomended ! Update; omg this is an amazing Grill Chicken Sandwich. Not only good looking but also delicious taste. Good job Nancy🙋🏻♂️”
“The food is consistently delicious, and you can really taste the quality in every bite — from the perfectly baked crust to the rich, flavorful sauce and generous toppings. The staff is always friendly, attentive, and makes you feel welcome from the moment you walk in. Whether dining in or ordering for takeout, everything comes out hot, fresh, and exactly as expected. It’s clear they take pride in what they do. Definitely one of the best spots around for authentic Chicago-style pizza and great service. Highly recommend to anyone who loves real, hearty pizza done right! 🍕👏dont missed to try fried Calamari”
“uch delicious pasta! 😍 Creamy sauce, tender mushrooms, juicy chicken fillet, and perfectly cooked fettuccine. Even the simple toasts were just 🔥 — crispy and flavorful. The salad was fresh and light. The atmosphere is cozy with a touch of autumn mood — even the little pumpkin on the table adds to the charm. I’ll definitely come back again! 🍝🎃”
“Nancy’s Pizza on Broadway is absolutely fantastic! The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the staff is always attentive and friendly. Their deep dish is a true Chicago classic—perfectly baked with a buttery crust, gooey cheese, and rich tomato sauce that’s full of flavor. The thin crust options are also great if you’re in the mood for something lighter, but still packed with taste. Everything came out hot and fresh, and the service was fast despite how busy it was. You can tell they really care about quality. Whether you’re a local or just visiting Chicago, this location is a must for authentic Chicago pizza. Highly recommended! 🍕🔥”
“One of the best pizza restaurants I tried in Chicago is Nacy's Pizza. Their stuffed pizzas are especially delicious, and the restaurant has a very pleasant atmosphere. Three friends and I went there, and I had pasta with pesto sauce. The pasta is amazing. They also have a wide variety of drinks. The red wine was delicious. Just a note for first-timers: if you order stuffed pizza, it takes a bit longer to cook, around 20-25 minutes.”
“It was my first time trying a stuffed pizza and it was so delicious( we ordered a party one) We had a very charming and nice server,she helped us a lot. Calamari Frits and Greek salad were insanely good too. Atmosphere and workers are such a nice people. This place looks so Cozy.”
“The place is now under new management. We ordered a deep dish (stuffed) pepperoni pizza and an antipasto salad (both were generous in size and good in quality). The restaurant appears to have been recently renovated, and the service was excellent. The only downside was that the restrooms could use a bit more attention in terms of cleanliness”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More Italian in Lakeview & North Center
See the ranking →
In the same lane · Italian, mid-range
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in Lakeview, minutes away.