First Slice Pie Cafe Manor
Dakota Trowbridge · 135 Google reviewsFirst Slice Pie Cafe Manor — Lincoln Square cafe anchored by the Pies. 259+ Google reviews. "The sandwich was one of the best ive had in a long time" — Dakota Trowbridge [$]
What 266 diners keep saying
What 266 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“This place is intimate and cozy with a small menu but everything on it looks amazing. I love how there are so many items to take to go. I've been here once but I'm excited to come back again soon!!”
“So I've never been to the physical location but my friends had their pies at a party and ever since I can't stop ordering from First Slice. I'm obsessed with their sandwiches! They have the BEST combo. Sandwich + salad + chips & I always add a slice of pie too. My favorite pie is key lime I think but I've tried a hand full of theirs and they are all delicious. They have a really unique yummy balsamic pear pie. Their apple and cherry pies are phenomenal too. Looking forward to trying more things on the menu. Oh and my daughter loves their Mac and cheese. Thanks for feeding us! <3”
“Stopped by on a whim and ordered a slice of the mango margarita cheesecake pie (pictured) and the broccoli cheddar quiche. Both were amazing! Great, helpful service and chill vibe as well.”
“Awesome food with awesome service. The pies are great. Try their cafe sandwiches.”
“The French silk pie is the bomb. Also the Cuban sandwich is so zesty and tasty!!! Loved them both. Sorry, I ate the Cuban before getting a good picture!”
“Nice little spot, great for lunch. Sandwiches are good and the baked goods are amazing. The blueberry cheesecake was delicious 😋”
“Great food, very nice staff. Amazingly affordable for home cooked meals.”
“Delicious pies to go! Can't wait to go back and dine-in!”
“I get the pre made family meals from this place. They blow any other meal service out of the water on quality of ingredients and taste. More expensive than HelloFresh and those other companies but 1000x tastier and you’re supporting small business!”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More cafe in Lakeview & North Center
See the ranking →
In the same lane · budget
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in Lincoln Square, minutes away.