The Original Nottoli & Son
Keith “N.” M · 276 Google reviewsThe Original Nottoli & Son — one of Northwest Side's strongest italian spots. Nothing about this place is trying to impress you, and that's the point. The food tastes like it should, with no compromises. White Knight: "Their Vodka Rigatoni is the kind of dish that sticks with you long after your meal is over—rich, creamy" [$, patio]
What 1,052 diners keep saying
What 1,052 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“Nottoli on Harlem is great gem thats been around for a long time to get a cold/hot sandwiches 🥪 😋. Great Italian deli to get cold cuts,sausages, bread,hot and cold sandwiches, other hot foods. It does get real busy but the ladies making the food are professionals and they get the line moving pretty fast. Shout out to Patty hard working lady, i tell you what!! I got the beef combo sandwiches 🥪 beef was nice and juicy enough juice on the bread where it's not too soggy. The hot Italian sausage was juicy and flavorful. I added provolone cheese and giardiniera to the sandwiche. I also bought one of their homemade pickles one of the best tasting pickles I ever had i recommended it 10/10 will buy more than 2 again lol. Pot Roast sandwiches are also delicious so is their Italian subs. They also cater for parties 🥳 . Stop by and get a bite to eat here you won't be disappointed. Be mindful does get pretty busy during lunch time.”
“While in town visiting a long time friend he asked me what I wanted for lunch on way to the airport. When I answered an Italian Sub sandwich he said Nottoli was the place. Well Nottoli didn’t disappoint! Enjoyed a 6” Italian sub, with a side of Italian sausage! Food is super fresh and made to order! Owner is also a nice friendly guy too.”
“I came in early on a Saturday, order the Italian with hot peppers, everything and extra dressing. By the time I got done eating and chatting with the lovely staff, the line was wrapped around the table to the door. IF YOUR IN A RUSH, call your order in and grab it to go, the sandwich tastes great even a few hours later. In my opinion I like it a couple hours later, it gives the bread a chance to soak up the goodness!!!!!!!! 🙏♥️”
“The Italian sandwich I picked up from Nottoli was incredible. Every layer of meat tasted fresh and full of flavor. The Volpi salami had a rich bite, the prosciutto cotto was tender, the hot capicollo brought just enough heat, and the mortadella tied everything together with that smooth, classic taste. The provolone added the right amount of sharpness without taking over. What really pushed it over the top was the bread. Soft on the inside with a light crunch on the outside and it tasted like it was baked that morning. You can tell they care about their ingredients because nothing felt processed or thrown together. It is the kind of sandwich where you finish it and immediately think about ordering another. If you are anywhere near Nottoli this is one of those things you should try at least once.”
“I’m from the country and a college buddy used to bring this sausage to school. Finally got to visit this weekend and what a beautiful authentic gem this establishment is. Great sandwich, macaroni salad, and I got frozen sausage to take back!”
“Outstanding sandwiches, salads, and service, as always.”
“Good old fashioned Italian deli I've had on the "want to go" list forever and finally got to go. You can order a la carte deli items such as salads meats and keep it a lighter lunch if you wish like I did today. I'll definitely be back for more when I'm in the area! Seating is limited and tight, benches and some outdoor tables.”
“Pot roast sandwich phenomenal. Macaroni salad amazing. I cant say anymore. It was very good soft and juicy. The roast juice was soaked up by the bread. Chicken parm juicy not dry. A great experience. A very palatable encounter!!!”
“I cannot say enough good things. I’ve been coming here for years. Today I happened to be in the area and stopped in. Macaroni salad, 9” Italian sub, lemon taralli. All excellent. The taralli dough tasted like bread my grandmother used to make and the glaze was perfect. Great solid sandwiches, awesome sides. This place is a gem.”
“Nottoli’s is a weekly tradition for us. It’s perfect and amazing for every occasion. I even get nottoli’s when I host people. Everyone who works there is awesome. Standouts: Italian, pot roast, chicken cutlet. I’m writing this review as I eat my leftover cutlet sandwich. One of my favorite places ever.”
“One of the best places for some authentic Italian foods and commodities. They don't disappoint, just an opinion. Worth the wait when you have to. The people and family there are wonderful. I was introduced to their deli many years ago and will continues to go out my way when time is available to grab a bite from the place”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More Italian in Uptown & North Side
See the ranking →
In the same lane · Italian, budget
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in Northwest Side, minutes away.