Erie Cafe
david chen · 305 Google reviewsErie Cafe — honest italian in River North. Classic neighborhood feel, nothing here chasing trends. The cocktail list is worth exploring, and handles groups well. "Johnny was amazing as the phenomenal staff was as well" — Samantha Witz [$$$, patio]
What 808 diners keep saying
What 808 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“This cute old Chicago style Italian steakhouse was cute! The atmosphere reminds you of a calmer and simpler time. Felt homey. Drinks were served quickly and were tasty. We got different classic cocktails of an old fashion, dirty martini, and French 75. Food were LARGE servings. Entrees came with a side salad. The mashed potatoes, sautéed mushrooms, and cheese ravioli were the best. The steak came out pretty undercooked. They fixed this quickly and had the steak cooked quickly.”
“I had a really great experience at Erie Cafe. Honestly, this place is how every restaurant should be run. Right from the start, the complimentary valet parking makes everything easy and stress free. When you walk in, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the staff makes you feel taken care of right away. Service was excellent, everyone was friendly, attentive, and just genuinely nice without overdoing it. The food was fresh, tasted great, and was cooked exactly how I asked. You can tell they care about quality and consistency. Overall, it’s just a solid spot that gets everything right service, food, and experience. I’d definitely recommend it.”
“This is the fourth time over the last 18 years I've eaten here. Never disappointed. If you want old school comfort food Chicago Italian Steakhouse it will not be much better than this. Low key, business dinner or family there is a great menu for all. Definitely try grilled calamari. Wife had ChickParm I did filet. Perfect. Save room for the carrot cake.”
“We came here for a new year's eve dinner and was not disappointed. The red wine recommended by the waiter and the food was all terrific. The crab cake was especially good and we loved it very much. Only downside of this restaurant is that on a busy night, it's really hard to hear each other and we had to yell to each other a bit like in a club.”
“Wow - phenomenal experience at a birthday party in the upstairs private room at Erie Cafe. Johnny and the service team were awesome and the food was unbelievable. Timeless Chicago vibes…Planning to come back soon!”
“The best local. The patio is a great place to relax in the summer months with a drink and a bit to eat. The calamari and cocktails are both excellent”
“Great outdoor patio for wine and food, MARTIN is the best sommelier ever, please give him a promotion and raise in salary. Cheers #goodjuice”
“This place is a little nondescript on the outside but it is a absolute gem of a spot. The inside of the restaurant has a beautiful classic vibe with that old school charm, I loved the ambiance. Service is exceptional, they were welcoming, friendly, and very attentive. The food is delicious, everything was very tasty and well prepared. Price point is a bit high, but given the quility of food, exceptional service, and location, I feel it is a good value. I highly recommend Erie Cafe! During the summer you can sit outside and enjoy the weather. There is some free parking behind the building.”
“아들 생일기념으로 오픈테이블 통해 일주일 전에 예약을 했는데 주방통로 앞 자리에 앉았어요. 다음에 가게 된다면 부스 자리로 미리요청해야겠어요. 스테이크가 간이 좀 덜 됐는지 아들은 A1소스에 계속 찍어 먹더라구요. 베이크드클램은 맛있었어요. 해감에 신경쓰셔야할것같아요.조개껍질이 씹혔어요. 전반적으로 만족합니다.”
“Great place for lunch. The food was good. The salmon was way too condiment. Service was great.”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More Italian in Downtown & River North
See the ranking →
In the same lane · Italian, upscale
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in River North, minutes away.