Carmine's
Emer A. · 311 Google reviewsCarmine's — clean, consistent italian in Gold Coast. Order the tiramisu. Old-school in the best sense, with zero pretense. "The best was the entree, the New York strip steak, which was perfectly cooked" — Alex [$$$, patio]
What 1,793 diners keep saying
What 1,793 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“Warning you about large portions... The Chicken parmesan was huuuge. But food is great! I also really liked the stuffed mushrooms, brushetta, and the stacked eggplant. The staff were very attentive and friendly! Love the terrace. Definitely recommend.”
“Joe the GM at Carmine’s made me feel like a regular. The new upstairs area has plenty of seating. Food was great.”
“Superb food, and even better service. I highly recommend the eggplant stack and their house-made pappardelle, food was honestly to die for. Our servers Alfredo and Sara were so nice and accommodating, we felt well taken care of.”
“تجربة عشاء ثم غذاء ممتازة في المطعم الجلسات الخارجية لطيفة جدا والداخلية ايضا الطعام ايطالي لذيذ والقائمة متنوعة السلطات لذيذة وكميتها وفيرة الحلويات رائعة الخدمة ممتازة جدا”
“Welcome back! Went back to Carmines tonight for dinner and blown away! Two years later the quality still stands, the portions still impressive and their martini still the best in town. The classics remain so but that eggplant Parmesan was super. Loved the baked clams and I think the patio wins! Go dine just for the service and the rush street vibes! @chicagopescetarian”
“Wow! Great renovation! Bill was our server and couldn't have been better. Lovely late lunch. The decor is amazing. Really, really beautiful. Live the orange booths!”
“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Carmine’s as part of a BSA-sponsored dinner, and the experience exceeded expectations from start to finish. The atmosphere is warm, elegant, and inviting, making it an excellent venue for both business gatherings and special occasions. Our group was comfortably accommodated, and the restaurant provided the perfect setting for networking, conversation, and a great meal. The food was outstanding. The eggplant parmesan was absolutely delicious, and every dish that came to the table was prepared with care and served in generous portions. The quality and flavor were evident in every bite. The service was equally impressive. The staff was attentive, professional, and ensured our group was well taken care of throughout the evening. From arrival to departure, everything ran smoothly. The valet service was also a wonderful convenience and added to the overall positive experience. If you’re looking for a restaurant that combines exceptional food, outstanding service, and a sophisticated atmosphere, Carmine’s is a fantastic choice. Our BSA-sponsored dinner was a great success, and it’s easy to see why this restaurant continues to be a favorite for both business functions and personal celebrations.”
“They nailed the redesign. The food and service are outstanding. You can tell they brought the right team in to make this place special.”
“We’ve been to Carmine’s on Rush 3 times since they have opened. We dream about the Italian Ice, lasagna and chicken parmesan. 2 times we sat at the bar upstairs. Fun vibe and music. The portions are huge and the ambiance is gorgeous. Can’t wait for the outside patio to open! So wonderful to have a classic Italian restaurant in the neighborhood!”
“The food is delicious, the ambiance is great and the service was perfect. We are so happy Carmine's is back in our neighborhood.”
“Massive dish size - do share ;) lovely place, with a louder music”
“Listen… everybody cannot get me outside in negative 35-degree Chicago weather at night 😩❄️ But for my goddaughter’s 18th birthday, I did it and let me tell you, it was WORTH IT. Every negative degree. Every layer of clothing. Every step outside 😂 Italian food is my absolute favorite, so I was excited to see that Carmine’s Italian Restaurant is back open and just in time for Chicago Restaurant Week! 🙌🏽 The $60 Restaurant Week menu did not disappoint. For appetizers, you can choose between stuffed mushrooms or calamari. For salads, there’s the caprese or Caesar salad. Quick note: the Caesar dressing does include anchovies, which gives it a strong, authentic Italian flavor so if you’re sensitive to that or have allergies, just keep that in mind. For your main course, you can choose from a variety of pastas like cheese ravioli, spaghetti and meatballs, and more or go for an entrée. I had the chicken parmesan, and baby… it was EVERYTHING 😌🍝 And for dessert, you get to choose between tiramisu or cheesecake. The portion sizes? Let’s just say they understood the assignment 👏🏽 I was so hungry that I started eating before taking pictures, so I only snapped my entrée 😏 The staff was friendly, the vibe was intimate yet spacious, and the aesthetics were beautiful. Carmine’s used to be one level, but now it’s two levels, and the space feels warm, elevated, and welcoming. I’m honestly just happy that Carmine’s is back open. And yes I’ll definitely be going back. If you’re looking for a cozy Italian spot with great food and atmosphere, do yourself a favor and check out Carmine’s. 🇮🇹✨”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More Italian in Downtown & River North
See the ranking →
In the same lane · Italian, upscale
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in Gold Coast, minutes away.