All Too Well - Armitage
Nick · 222 Google reviewsAll Too Well - Armitage — reliable american in Old Town. There's imagination in the cooking here, and no long waits. "The beef itself was a tender, perfectly-seasoned dream" — E Suyat [$$]
What 192 diners keep saying
What 192 diners keep saying
verbatim, from Google
“Adding additional comments because I ordered the Ck1 sandwich today for lunch and seriously one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had! Great spot for a quick lunch, served quickly, loved the atmosphere and the sandwich was amazing!”
“The sandwich was delicious and was served on the fluffiest bread. No idea where it’s from or even what kind it is, but I’ll gladly take that gluten pillow any time, any place.”
“We stopped in on a lark and split the CK1- absolute delight. We didn’t have any particular expectations beyond a hot sandwich, and were very pleasantly surprised. The whole menu looked unusual but good, picked the CK1 and strongly recommend it. For a not-too-heavy lunch, half the sandwich was just right. It came out very hot, we actually let it rest a moment before we could pick it up and eat it, then it was delicious, particularly dipped in the Au jus. We would have come back again if they were open later!”
“Very delicious sandwich shop not far from the zoo. Went around noon and still got food quickly. Wide variety of flavors and fairly priced.”
“great veggie sandwich. cute space and lots of seating options. i’d of course love another veg option but considering it’s a small menu i’m satisfied.”
“Okay this place is amazing. It’s all in the name! I got a Ruben and it was phenomenal. The ingredients taste so fresh and it was the perfect size. Staff was super sweet and the aroma of the place was cozy. Will be returning 100%!”
“Such a great neighborhood spot! The sandwiches are so unique and absolutely delicious.”
“Really good sandwich restaurant. CK1 was super delicious, au jus was also awesome. Tons of flavor and not your average roast beef sandwich for sure. Wish they would add a *little* more meat but portions are good. Interior of the restaurant is nicely setup, although not super big so finding a spot might not be the easiest. Friendly staff and clean environment. Prices are about average. Food came out in a reasonable amount of time. Definitely recommend for a nice sandwich in the Lincoln Park neighborhood.”
“I usually don’t leave reviews but All Too Well was really really good! The service was great, super welcoming and kind. Also, I got the Bombay Chulet which was a great portion sizes for one person or even two people who aren’t starving. The ingredients were fresh and the bread was delicious. Also, there is a huge variety of unique combinations for the sandwiches. Will definitely be coming back.”
“Definitely worth the walk, I got the CK1 and it was amazing”
“We got the “I make you lamb” and the “CK1” CK 1 was unique with the tabouli, but closer to your typical Chicago style Italian beef. The I make you lamb, bread, pickled onions, cheese and sauce were delicious. But unfortunately, the lamb was severely overcooked. You couldn’t even chew it further, you had to just swallow what you could. I had to take it completely out of the sandwich. For $16, it totally missed the mark. Lamb should be soft, tender and barely need chewing- but at least be able to be chewed when necessary. Staff was really nice. Location is cute, either way decent inside seating.”
Sounds like your kind of place?
Star it — your hit list is where dinner decisions get made.
One email a month — new openings, hidden gems, and where locals are actually eating.
More American in Lincoln Park & Old Town
See the ranking →
In the same lane · American, mid-range
If it's packed, walk to…
More good rooms in Old Town, minutes away.